2) Manchester United 0-0 Exeter City (2005)
Andy Taylor missed two chances to hand Exeter a shock victory at Old Trafford. The former United trainee squandered both his opportunities and the Premier League side eventually progressed via a replay. City boss Alex Inglethorpe said at the time: “I am incredibly proud of the team, not just for the way we played but the way we have conducted ourselves throughout the build-up.”