Robbie Keane – Tottenham Hotspur (2009-2011)
After six years at White Hart Lane, Keane signed for Benitez at Liverpool in 2008. However, the Irishman could never find form at Anfield, scoring a paltry five goals in 19 games.
Before being almost chased out of Anfield for a waste of £19 million, Keane returned to Spurs to play just six months after leaving under new manager Redknapp.